The 3Cs: How to Deliver Feedback That Lasts


Even the most experienced managers may sweat at the prospect of delivering a performance evaluation. These delicate conversations require speaking in just the right tone and communicating with utmost clarity, especially when emotions run high. UNC Professor Elad Sherf recommends using the framework of the three Cs — Clarity, Contextual Meaning, and Composure — as a guide for turning every performance review into an opportunity to demonstrate empathy and help employees achieve lasting growth, learning, and improvement.

Feedback Trap

Advice on how managers can deliver more effective feedback abounds in venerable business media and social media “listicles” alike. Yet according to Elad, this advice often falls short. Directions to “be specific” and “focus on the behavior, not the person” are too ambiguous to provide managers with real insight. Further, managers themselves may fall into this “ambiguity trap.” Evaluations such as, “you are not doing well enough,” leave employees ill-equipped to know precisely how they should improve going forward.

The 3Cs for Feedback That Lasts

With practice, managers can use the three Cs to deliver constructive feedback that provides transparent direction (Clarity), emphasizes employees’ goals (Contextual Meaning), and negotiates employees’ affective reactions (Composure).

Clarity: The “Content”

Effective feedback provides specific information on two elements of an employee’s performance. The first element focuses on the employee’s past actions and behaviors. This presents managers with a golden opportunity to be specific. Rather than speaking in broad, general evaluations (e.g., “the presentation was not compelling enough”), communicate how the employee’s specific actions and behaviors contributed to them exceeding, meeting, or falling short of expectations.

The second element of effective feedback focuses on the future. Give the employee precise directions about what they should do to improve their performance next time.

Contextual Meaning: The “Why”

No conversation exists in a vacuum. Rather, our interactions are rich with contextual meaning that flows from our backgrounds, relationships, experiences, and, crucially, our goals.

During a performance evaluation, employees implicitly want to hear, “What does this feedback mean for my bonus, promotion, or professional reputation?” Managers who successfully identify and connect their feedback to each employee’s unique goals will deliver a more impactful and longer-lasting message.

Composure: The “Response”

Managers who wish to deliver effective feedback must leverage their emotional intelligence. Before a performance review, identify the emotions the employee is likely to experience during the conversation. Then craft your message with the relevant feeling in mind. For example, understanding how an employee will interpret feedback about their career goals, and then shifting the conversation to how their goals can still be achieved, can help disarm anger or anxiety.

Delivering feedback is among a manager’s greatest challenges. The three Cs provide a practical, psychology-based framework that will help managers deliver more effective feedback. By leveraging Clarity, Contextual Meaning, and Composure, managers can adapt their feedback conversations to the unique needs of each employee and provide an actionable roadmap for improved learning, growth, and performance going forward.

If you would like to learn more about how you can improve your employee evaluations, download our full white paper, The 3Cs of Delivering Effective Feedback. This resource expands on the psychology behind the three Cs and includes tools for preparing and structuring your feedback conversations.

Elad Sherf

Associate Professor of Organizational Behavior and Sarah Graham Kenan Scholar, UNC Kenan-Flagler Business School

Related Content

Discover how our transformational learning experiences deliver results for our corporate sector clients.

  • How to Strengthen Your Sales Leadership Talent Pipeline

    Learn how to build a strong sales leadership pipeline by identifying future organizational leaders within sales teams, developing essential leadership skills, and creating clear internal growth pathways.

  • How UNC Helped Service Logic Lead With Impact 

    Learn how a leading HVAC service network partnered with UNC Executive Development to elevate leadership. Through a custom executive education program, the company is fostering collaboration and driving strategic innovation.

  • Brain-Based Tools for Smarter Negotiations

    Discover how neuroscience can transform negotiation skills. Learn brain-based strategies to boost creativity, emotional regulation, and resilience for smarter, more successful negotiations.

  • Generative AI at Work: Stay Creative, Stay Compliant

    Learn how to use generative AI at work to boost creativity while staying compliant with copyright laws. Discover key strategies to reduce legal risks and ensure ethical AI use.

  • Building Resilient Supply Chains in a Changing World

    In a world where disruption is the new normal, discover how forward-thinking leaders can transform supply chains into resilient, adaptive engines of competitive advantage.

Contact Us About Your Organization's Needs

Pavilion with columns and red flowering bushes at UNC
Linkedin logo Facebook logo Instagram logo Email envelope icon